Weak bones are often a problem for older people. Around 10 million Americans have a condition called osteoporosis, where bones become so weak they break easily. Having osteoporosis increases your risk of a damaged spine or a broken hip.
There are drugs for treating osteoporosis, but you might wonder whether lifestyle changes could help protect your bones. You probably know already that calcium plays an important part in keeping your bones healthy. Vitamin D also plays a part. Doctors often advise people with osteoporosis to take calcium and vitamin D supplements, usually together with medications.
It's also possible that eating fruit and vegetables could help keep your bones strong. The theory goes like this. Western diets are typically high in protein and cereals. These foods are broken down into acids. Too much acid in your body can encourage calcium and other minerals to be released from bones, making them weaker.
Fruits and vegetables are broken down into a chemical called bicarbonate. This helps neutralize acids. So, the idea is that eating fruits and vegetables, or taking a bicarbonate supplement, could prevent the breakdown of your bones.
There's some evidence for this theory. A new study looked at 162 healthy volunteers older than 50 years of age. Half were given bicarbonate supplements, like potassium carbonate or sodium bicarbonate (just the same as baking soda). Others got a pretend (placebo) treatment or a potassium chloride supplement.
People who took the bicarbonate supplements had less calcium in their urine. That could mean that their bodies weren't breaking down the calcium in their bones.
Unfortunately, the study only lasted three months, and only looked at blood and urine samples. It didn't directly measure the strength of people's bones. So, we can't tell for sure whether bicarbonate supplements would stop people getting broken bones.
The researchers think that eating more fruit and vegetables could have similar effects to taking bicarbonate supplements. However, they admit that to get the same effect would take drastic changes to someone's diet, which might be difficult, especially for older people who have long-established eating habits.
What you need to know. Eating more fruit and vegetables has many health benefits, but judging by this study, it's not yet clear whether changing your diet can make a difference to the strength of your bones. Likewise, it's too early to say whether bicarbonate supplements will help keep bones strong, and they may have side effects.
—Philip Wilson, patient editor, BMJ Group
ConsumerReportsHealth.org has partnered with The BMJ Group to monitor the latest medical research and assess the evidence to help you decide which news you should use.
Read more about preventing osteoporosis and avoiding falls, and take a look at our Treatment Ratings (subscribers only) to find out how regular exercise can help keep bones strong.












Previous









Post a comment
Comments: