Top Product Ratings:  Ellipticals  |  Hospitals  |  Tooth whiteners  |  Blood-glucose meters  |  Insurance plans  |  Blood-pressure monitors  |  Treadmills
| More
Vitamins not vital for many kids who take them
Feb 10, 2009 5:15 PM

Child and milk My husband and I have an informal division of labor for many household and parenting tasks. (On his list: garbage, lawn care, dressing the kids in the morning. On mine: bills, laundry, getting the kids ready for bed at night.) At dinnertime he usually cooks and I, well, fret about nutrition. I'm not (I hope) an overly anxious parent, but I do worry about my preschool son's eating habits. He doesn't like milk, turns up his nose at many kid-friendly staples (what child doesn't like spaghetti?), and shies away from most green vegetables (although he does love peas—if they're frozen). So, for some added nutritional insurance, I've been contemplating giving him a multivitamin. But does he really need that extra jolt of nutrients? Possibly not.

New research shows that most children who take vitamins probably don't need them, and that kids who could benefit most from these supplements are least likely to take them. The research comes from a national study of more than 10,800 children ages 2 to 17. In questionnaires and interviews, parents were asked about their child's health and nutrition, including questions about their use of vitamin and mineral supplements.

Researchers found that one third of children and teenagers had taken supplements recently, and that almost half of these youngsters took supplements daily. But, contrary to what researchers expected, kids with poorer diets and less active lifestyles were among the least likely to take vitamins, even though they were at greater risk of deficiencies. On the flipside, kids who were healthy and active and had good diets were most likely to take vitamins, even though they were least likely to need them.

Family income also was closely linked to vitamin use. Kids from low-income families were much less likely to take supplements—not surprising, perhaps, given that a 100-count bottle of a multivitamin can top $10.

What you need to know. So does your child need to take vitamins? If he or she is healthy and eats a varied diet, the general answer is no, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics. But check with your doctor if you aren't sure whether your child's diet is varied enough. I, for one, am planning to ask whether my son might be low on vitamin D, since he doesn't drink much milk and isn't getting much D-boosting sun during the winter. And one more thing: my son, who loves animals, announced last week that he doesn't want to eat meat anymore. Any tips on feeding a finicky vegetarian?

Sophie Ramsey, patient editor, BMJ Group

ConsumerReportsHealth.org has partnered with The BMJ Group to monitor the latest medical research and assess the evidence to help you decide which news you should use. 

Take a look at our tips on helping your child maintain healthy eating habits and read our research on vitamins and minerals.

Post a comment

Comments:

1
Expand All
Collapse All